TexasIsHot – Energy Efficiency

Lighting Tips

Sep 16 2009

Incandescent vs. CFL vs. LED Light Bulb

cfl_light_bulbFor anyone out there dragging their feet about switching to Compact Fluorescent (CFL) or LED light bulbs in the home, I’ve done some research and put together some data about long-term usage in comparison to incandescent bulbs. As anyone paying attention has noticed, incandescent bulbs are rapidly becoming a thing of the past in terms of price, output, and performance. In an attempt to shed some light on the issue, we’ve crunched some numbers and put together an Excel sheet that compares various facets of incandescent, CFL and LED bulbs. Read the rest of our analysis after the jump, and feel free to download our Light Bulb Comparison Spreadsheet, which you can customize for your own home bulb comparisons.

Next time you’re out looking for light bulbs for your home, consider your options and bear in mind a few factors that go into differentiating your options: individual bulb price, lifespan, lumens (brightness), and wattage/electricity cost (how much electricity it takes to light the bulb). Before you try to figure out which bulb you want to buy, consider what your goals are. Do you want to the longest-lasting bulb you can find? Do you want the most efficient bulb? Do you want to stop changing bulbs for 15 years? These days, there’s an option for each of these concerns.

The incandescent bulb is a dinosaur. About the only thing it has going for it in comparison to more efficient and longer-lasting options is that the price of an individual bulb is still comparatively low. But if you use a little foresight, you’ll realize there are better options out there that cost just a little more. If you want a bulb that’s going to last for extended periods between replacements, you’ll want to go with the LED. The bulb features a lifespan of 60,000 hours versus the CFL’s 10,000 hours and the incandescent bulb’s 1,500 hours. Considering the bulb’s low energy expenditure, the cost (over its 60,000-hour lifespan) is significantly lower than either of the other bulbs. Simply put, if using as little energy as possible is your goal, the LED bulb is for you.

Of course, the standard LED is generally less bright than a traditional bulb. We tested the Spotlight LED bulb, which is made by the same manufacturer as the bulb we compared in our analysis (but with a lower lumen count), and we found it to have only a slightly less brightness than the traditional bulb. The LED also has the major drawback of featuring a very direct field of light, which makes it most useful only when aimed directly at what you want to light. Standard floor and table lamps equipped with an LED tend to offer streams of light aimed at the ceiling, which may not help with that book you’re reading.

As a versatile bulb that burns comparably bright to a standard incandescent, but still costs less over the long term and burns more efficiently, the CFL Bulb may be your best bet. An advantage the CFL has over the LED is an upfront-cost that is considerably lower and far closer to the incandescent. In fact, if overall cost is your only concern, the cost of new LED bulbs may be more than you want to spend. Over the life of an LED, you are only going to see dramatic savings over the CFL if you are in an area that has high energy costs. For example, we compared LED and CFL bulbs at a standard $0.10 rate, and found that you would save about $11 over 60,000 hours. We also compared the two at $0.33 (what a friend pays) where the savings jumps to $120 over the life of an LED.

While the CFL is twice as expensive as the incandescent upfront, the former buries the latter in a pile of long-term cost. Each individual setting—not to mention the user’s view’s on energy conservation—is going to call for a unique bulb. We’ve tried to give you basic data and tools to figure out which bulb is right for you. Download the Excel spreadsheet and consider the best options for you.

Source : www.productdose.com

LightBulb_Comparison Spreadsheet

Tagged , , , ,

Related Posts

9 Comments

  1. Craig BryantMarch 3, 2011 at 10:39 amReply

    In the long term, LED lamps purchased at current prices reflect a significant savings in energy, part replacement, and replacement labor over both incandescent and Compact Fluorescent (CFL) lighting. However, LED pricing is still a major deterrent for most consumers.

    LED technology is moving forward quite rapidly in terms of brightness and efficiency, and manufacturing costs will soon be significantly lower than CFLs. So as LED prices drop to attractive levels, expect CFLs to join incandescent lamps with their own dinosaur status in the not too distant future. This will be gratifying to see because there are some disturbing problems with CFLs. Heated mercury vapor inside CFLs creates UV which causes the phosphor coating inside the glass to fluoresce and produce light. Every year in our nation alone, we dump tons of mercury into our environment in the form of discarded fluorescent lights.

    Unlike CFLs, LED’s contain no mercury and present no environmental threat, and LED’s emit no UV. This is good news for the environment inside our homes, and for the outside environment we all share together.

  2. adminMarch 21, 2011 at 12:38 pmReplyAuthor

    Thought so too. I think what most people find is that as they will reap savings sooner than anticipated. Most of the numbers shown in the chart are fairly conservative.

  3. LouisApril 12, 2012 at 3:50 amReply

    Green CFL bulbs look nice. I have heard about such CFL bulbs but not sure whether to use them at home. Saving money and hpinleg the environment both at a same time is a brilliant idea. Thanks for posting the video also. I hope like me, many readers will also plan to change the lighting of their home to these green CFL bulbs.

  4. JoelApril 14, 2012 at 10:54 pmReply

    I bought CFLs about 5 years ago to elcrape all the incandescent bulbs in my house. Half of them burned out within a year. Now only 1 remains in service and that’s in the laundry room where the light is used only a few times on weekends. They absolutely failed for outdoor use because it gets below freezing here in the winter; they wouldn’t light up at all. So last year I bought a case of 60 and 100 watt long life light bulbs from Halco. Hopefully that will last me until there are economical alternatives to CFLs. Maybe I should have bought two cases of each

  5. Online LightingApril 16, 2012 at 3:47 amReply

    Ya I like it. Its very informative post. Thanks for share it. A light-emitting diode (LED) is a semiconductor light source. LEDs are used as indicator lamps in many devices and are increasingly used for other lighting. Introduced as a practical electronic component in 1962, early LEDs emitted low-intensity red light, but modern versions are available across the visible, ultraviolet, and infrared wavelengths, with very high brightness.

  6. energy saver storeApril 17, 2012 at 6:19 amReply

    Great post. Keep us update with your developments!

  7. LED Panel LightMay 7, 2012 at 2:26 amReply

    expect CFLs to join incandescent lamps with their own dinosaur status in the not too distant future. This will be gratifying to see because there are some disturbing problems with CFLs. Heated mercury vapor inside CFLs creates UV which causes

    • LucasNovember 17, 2012 at 5:48 amReply

      Well the CFL definitely doesn’t stay cold, but it’s much coleor than an incandescent bulb. We have a couple of different brands now the Wal-Mart ones take slightly longer to get all the way bright, but they’re not too noticeable. Another brand we have (GE) doesn’t have that problem at all. You can check out reviews on Amazon.com to see which ones do and don’t. I’m off to check out the video!

  8. 46 yr old Winston-born and raised Feyyaz Mccaughan is hooked on LED bulb, signed memorabilia, games. Last of all his motivation stems from discovering new places and countries to give an example Hamada.July 22, 2013 at 3:22 amReply

    I just now including the worthwhile info people provide on your own content articles. I’m going to search for ones site plus test out yet again listed here regularly. I’m rather selected Let me learn lots of fresh stuff in this article! Best of luck for an additional!

Leave a Reply to Online Lighting Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Testimonials
  • "“As the Texas population continues to grow, so will our energy consumption needs. We must have tools that empower the consumer to choose their products and monitor their usage wisely. TexasIsHot.org is a great resource, which is exactly what Texans need in today’s deregulated market.”" - State Rep. Burt Solomons (R-Carrollton), Chairman of House State Affairs Committee
  • "In order to meet our goals, we need programs like the TexasIsHot campaign to help change the way people think about energy." - State Sen. Troy Fraser (R-Horseshoe Bay), Chairman of Senate Natural Resources Committee
  • "Texas leads the nation in wind power because it makes money, not because it makes us feel better. Texans are a practical, penny-wise people who I think will be happy to learn how to save a few bucks on their power bills with the common-sense advice at TexasIsHot.org."-Jerry Patterson, Commissioner of the Texas General Land Office
  • "If every Texas household adopted just a few of the dozens of energy efficiency strategies referenced on TexasIsHot.org, our air would be cleaner, our limited supply of natural resources would be better protected, and our wallets would be heavier..." Kip Averitt (R-Waco), Former State Senator and Chairman of Senate Committee on Natural Resources
  • ”The TexasIsHot campaign targets an important piece of the clean energy effort -- educating Texans on the way we use electricity and quantifying the financial and environmental costs associated with our use. By just reducing the amount of electricity we use and waste, TexasIsHot.org can show people how to save money..." State Sen. Kirk Watson (D-Austin)
  • "Fluctuating energy costs are really hurting Texas families and businesses, but by just making a few easy changes, Texans can cut down on energy waste. TexasIsHot.org is a tremendous resource which arms consumers with the information they need to save themselves money by becoming more energy efficient, and help our environment." State Sen. Rodney Ellis (D-Houston)
  • "Texas is the third fastest growing state in the nation with a net growth of 1,000 people each and every day. This brings many challenges including providing clean and affordable electricity. That is why I'm excited about TexasIsHot.org. This website is an instructional resource that will help Texans save on their energy bills at home and in the workplace..." State Rep. Phil King (R-Weatherford)
  • "Now, more than ever, Texans need to work together to conserve energy and to make more efficient use of the energy we consume. The TexasIsHot.org website is an extraordinary resource for people who want to save money and help conserve our precious natural resources..." State Rep. Rafael Anchía (D-Dallas)
  • "By partnering with the TexasIsHot Coalition we can extend our effort’s reach, leverage our resources, and ensure that Austin’s energy grid continues to be a test-bed for technologies, products, and services that will transform our state’s energy system." Brewster McCracken, Executive Director, Pecan Street Project
  • "The City of Houston is working harder than ever to make Houston green and energy efficient, but we need the help of every citizen. I would encourage everyone to take a moment to explore the TexasIsHot website to learn what we can all do to make Houston, and the rest of Texas, the green and energy efficient example for the rest of the nation." Mayor Annise Parker, Houston
  • "Energy efficiency is one of our top priorities. Partnering with the TexasIsHot Coalition will help us educate citizens and local businesses about energy-efficient practices in order to meet our goal of reducing residential and commercial electric use." Gavin Dillingham, Chief of Sustainable Growth – General Services Department, for the City of Houston
  • "We are excited about the new partnership that the City of Corpus Christi has entered into with the TexasIsHot Coalition. TexasIsHot.org provides a platform to educate policy makers, city employees and citizens on how to save money and help the environment by conserving energy..." Mayor Joe Adame, Corpus Christi
  • "I am excited that the City of Corpus Christi has joined the TexasIsHot Coalition and look forward to working with them to help Texans become smarter energy users. Energy efficiency is by far the best way for people to reduce their bills and help the environment, but we need education and outreach to make this happen." State Rep. Solomon Ortiz, Jr (D-Corpus Christi)
  • "Because of its fast growth and hot summers, Texas has to get smarter about energy conservation. I applaud the efforts of Corpus Christi and TexasIsHot to help businesses and residents reap the benefits of increased efficiency." Senator Juan “Chuy” Hinojosa (D-McAllen)
  • "Energy efficiency is the cleanest, quickest and cheapest way to get smart about energy use, saving both money and the environment. I applaud the TexasIsHot Coalition in their effort to educate Texans about the benefits of energy efficiency..." Luke Metzger, Director, Environment Texas
Get Connected

Enter your email address and receive tips and helpful info from Texasishot.org