TexasIsHot – Energy Efficiency


Oct 18 2016

Federal clean energy plan looks like a “win-win” for Texas.

by david in Blog with 0 Comments

If Obama’s climate change plan is upheld in court, what would it mean for Texas?

Tom Benning
Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON — For John Dudley, wind power in Texas is a “win-win.” The 72-year-old rancher in Comanche County, two hours southwest of Dallas, hails the large wind farm that sits partly on his land as a boon to the local tax base. He appreciates the nice business sideline to his cattle operation. He even likes how the massive turbines look. But as the world awaits the legal fate of the Clean Power Plan — the sweeping climate change proposal that, among other things, would boost the wind industry — Dudley also admits that he doesn’t “much favor” the federal government telling “states what they should and shouldn’t do.” “I’m a big believer in states’ rights,” said Dudley, who declined to comment specifically on the plan. That kind of conflict underscores Texas’ complicated role in the ongoing debate over President Barack Obama’s signature proposal to cut power plants’ carbon dioxide emissions. Texas is better positioned than many states to meet the plans’ markers, thanks to market forces that have elevated natural gas, wind and solar. But the state, a hotbed of opposition to what some call a costly overreach, also has certain features that could prove challenging. With both sides digging in, Texas could help answer a key question raised recently in oral arguments before a federal appeals court: Just how transformational is the Clean Power Plan? “The devil is in the details, but they are both right,” said Kenneth Medlock, senior director of Rice University’s Center for Energy Studies.
The Environmental Protection Agency last year issued the plan, which seeks by 2030 to cut power plants’ carbon dioxide emissions by a third from 2005 levels. The proposal was critical to the White House joining other nations in a global agreement to combat climate change. Under the plan, EPA would task each state with an emissions goal. Texas would have to cut 51 million tons from its annual average of 241 million tons in 2012. The regulations would target coal-fired electric plants and, thus, would hit coal states like West Virginia the hardest. But the states would also be given some flexibility. “We’re not going to dictate to you exactly how you do it,” Obama said recently. “But if you don’t start reducing them, you’re going to have problems.” Still, Texas and 27 states last year sued the EPA. The U.S. Supreme Court paused the plan in February. A federal appeals court heard the case last month, with a ruling expected in the next several weeks. It’s likely that the Supreme Court will again weigh in on the plan. And adding to the drama is the 2016 presidential campaign, which could decide the proposal’s fate once and for all. Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton has cheered Obama’s climate push, vowing to press ahead with his agenda in the U.S. and abroad. But GOP nominee Donald Trump, who’ssaid climate change is a hoax, has pledged to repeal the regulations and others like it. “This is a huge case,” appellate judge Brett Kavanaugh said last month. “It has huge economic and political consequences.”
<p>At a recent White House event with President Barack Obama, Texas Tech climate scientist Katharine Hayhoe touted Texas' wind power: "Here's the cool thing about Texas. Did you know that already Texas is getting 10 percent of its electricity from wind?" (Al Drago/The New York Times)</p><p><br></p>

At a recent White House event with President Barack Obama, Texas Tech climate scientist Katharine Hayhoe touted Texas’ wind power: “Here’s the cool thing about Texas. Did you know that already Texas is getting 10 percent of its electricity from wind?” (Al Drago/The New York Times)

So what would it mean for the Lone Star State? Texas is the biggest carbon emitter in the U.S. It’s the heart and soul of the oil business. It’s a growing state with a large industrial base. But it’s also the epicenter of the natural gas boom. It’s by far the country’s top wind energy producer. It has significant solar potential.

And all sides agree that Texas has made strides toward a “cleaner” energy mix. “Texas knows energy,” Texas Tech University’s Katharine Hayhoe said at a recent White House event. “And here’s the cool thing about Texas. Did you know that already Texas is getting 10 percent of its electricity from wind?” In 1994, Texas’ electric power generation by source was 41 percent coal, 47 percent natural gas, 9 percent nuclear and 0 percent wind, according to the Energy Information Administration. By 2014, it was 34 percent coal, 47 percent natural gas, 9 percent nuclear and 9 percent wind. Experts point to the low price of natural gas as key to driving the market. There’s also been the increased buy-in on wind power from Texans such as Dudley, the rancher who said the turbines are “ultimately a good thing.” And Clean Power Plan boosters such as John Hall of the Environmental Defense Fund tout the EPA’s proposal as an incremental, yet significant step. Though Hall said the regulations are needed to force other states into emissions reductions, he argued that Texas is sitting pretty. His group recently updated its analysis to show that Texas would actually exceed the plan’s goals under “business-as-usual conditions.” “Because of the competitive market, Texas isn’t going to have to do anything else,” he said.

That argument doesn’t quite cut it for the plan’s detractors. “It’s one thing for a market, which reacts to commodity prices, to change the fuel mix for electricity,” said Scott Segal, a Dallas-bred attorney who represents energy companies in Washington. “It’s quite another for the government to require it by mandate.” But opponents don’t just object philosophically to what they see as an unlawful power grab. They also challenge the notion that there won’t be an impact on cost and reliability in Texas. One data point has come from the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, which operates the state’s main power grid. Its study said the climate plan could increase Texans’ energy bills by 16 percent by 2030, though critics point to other stats in disputing that.

Either way, Texas’ not-insubstantial fleet of coal-fired plants remains a key factor. Though many of those plants are heading toward the end of their functional life span, the Clean Power Plan could accelerate their demise. And some predict that would have an outsize impact on rural electric cooperatives, such as San Miguel Electric Cooperative in South Texas. In an affidavit filed in the legal battle, San Miguel’s general manager said its coal-fired plant isn’t expected to retire until 2037. The climate plan would effectively force an early closure, he said. To do that while meeting its financial obligations, customers would see higher bills. And more broadly, experts said, the treatment of Texas’ coal-fired plants could be central to answering just how far along the state would be in meeting the Clean Power Plan’s goals. “Is Texas a long way towards? Yes,” said Medlock, the Rice expert. “The fundamental issue is what you do with the coal-fired generation in the state. … If you start closing that stuff down, how do you make up the lost capacity?”

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  • "“As the Texas population continues to grow, so will our energy consumption needs. We must have tools that empower the consumer to choose their products and monitor their usage wisely. TexasIsHot.org is a great resource, which is exactly what Texans need in today’s deregulated market.”" - State Rep. Burt Solomons (R-Carrollton), Chairman of House State Affairs Committee
  • "In order to meet our goals, we need programs like the TexasIsHot campaign to help change the way people think about energy." - State Sen. Troy Fraser (R-Horseshoe Bay), Chairman of Senate Natural Resources Committee
  • "Texas leads the nation in wind power because it makes money, not because it makes us feel better. Texans are a practical, penny-wise people who I think will be happy to learn how to save a few bucks on their power bills with the common-sense advice at TexasIsHot.org."-Jerry Patterson, Commissioner of the Texas General Land Office
  • "If every Texas household adopted just a few of the dozens of energy efficiency strategies referenced on TexasIsHot.org, our air would be cleaner, our limited supply of natural resources would be better protected, and our wallets would be heavier..." Kip Averitt (R-Waco), Former State Senator and Chairman of Senate Committee on Natural Resources
  • ”The TexasIsHot campaign targets an important piece of the clean energy effort -- educating Texans on the way we use electricity and quantifying the financial and environmental costs associated with our use. By just reducing the amount of electricity we use and waste, TexasIsHot.org can show people how to save money..." State Sen. Kirk Watson (D-Austin)
  • "Fluctuating energy costs are really hurting Texas families and businesses, but by just making a few easy changes, Texans can cut down on energy waste. TexasIsHot.org is a tremendous resource which arms consumers with the information they need to save themselves money by becoming more energy efficient, and help our environment." State Sen. Rodney Ellis (D-Houston)
  • "Texas is the third fastest growing state in the nation with a net growth of 1,000 people each and every day. This brings many challenges including providing clean and affordable electricity. That is why I'm excited about TexasIsHot.org. This website is an instructional resource that will help Texans save on their energy bills at home and in the workplace..." State Rep. Phil King (R-Weatherford)
  • "Now, more than ever, Texans need to work together to conserve energy and to make more efficient use of the energy we consume. The TexasIsHot.org website is an extraordinary resource for people who want to save money and help conserve our precious natural resources..." State Rep. Rafael Anchía (D-Dallas)
  • "By partnering with the TexasIsHot Coalition we can extend our effort’s reach, leverage our resources, and ensure that Austin’s energy grid continues to be a test-bed for technologies, products, and services that will transform our state’s energy system." Brewster McCracken, Executive Director, Pecan Street Project
  • "The City of Houston is working harder than ever to make Houston green and energy efficient, but we need the help of every citizen. I would encourage everyone to take a moment to explore the TexasIsHot website to learn what we can all do to make Houston, and the rest of Texas, the green and energy efficient example for the rest of the nation." Mayor Annise Parker, Houston
  • "Energy efficiency is one of our top priorities. Partnering with the TexasIsHot Coalition will help us educate citizens and local businesses about energy-efficient practices in order to meet our goal of reducing residential and commercial electric use." Gavin Dillingham, Chief of Sustainable Growth – General Services Department, for the City of Houston
  • "We are excited about the new partnership that the City of Corpus Christi has entered into with the TexasIsHot Coalition. TexasIsHot.org provides a platform to educate policy makers, city employees and citizens on how to save money and help the environment by conserving energy..." Mayor Joe Adame, Corpus Christi
  • "I am excited that the City of Corpus Christi has joined the TexasIsHot Coalition and look forward to working with them to help Texans become smarter energy users. Energy efficiency is by far the best way for people to reduce their bills and help the environment, but we need education and outreach to make this happen." State Rep. Solomon Ortiz, Jr (D-Corpus Christi)
  • "Because of its fast growth and hot summers, Texas has to get smarter about energy conservation. I applaud the efforts of Corpus Christi and TexasIsHot to help businesses and residents reap the benefits of increased efficiency." Senator Juan “Chuy” Hinojosa (D-McAllen)
  • "Energy efficiency is the cleanest, quickest and cheapest way to get smart about energy use, saving both money and the environment. I applaud the TexasIsHot Coalition in their effort to educate Texans about the benefits of energy efficiency..." Luke Metzger, Director, Environment Texas
Get Connected

Enter your email address and receive tips and helpful info from Texasishot.org